Life table response experiments (LTRE) in R

R
population dynamics
matrix models
LTRE
ecology tutorial
Decompose the difference in growth between two matrices into per-element contributions in R, and see why the biggest vital-rate change need not matter most.
Author

Tidy Ecology

Published

2026-05-14

Modified

2026-10-14

Corrected 14 October 2026: the account of the trade-off said almost none of the net improvement comes from the reproductive boost; it now says the boost on its own adds more than the whole net improvement and the survival cost takes back slightly more than that.

Corrected 1 October 2026: the side-by-side comparison said adult survival dominates the contributions; it now says the adult-survival contribution is only slightly larger than the fecundity one, so the two are nearly equal and opposite.

Sensitivity analysis is prospective: it asks how the growth rate would respond to a hypothetical change in a vital rate. A life table response experiment turns the question around. Two populations, say a control and a treatment, or two sites, or two years, actually differ in their vital rates, and their growth rates differ as a result. The LTRE decomposes that observed difference in growth into a sum of contributions, one per matrix element, so you can see which rate differences drove the outcome. The headline lesson, which Caswell set out in 1989, is that a large difference in a vital rate need not produce a large contribution, because contribution is the difference weighted by how sensitive growth is to that rate. This post builds the decomposition in base R and shows exactly that reversal.

Two matrices to compare

The example is a long-lived plant measured under a control and a treatment. The treatment raises fecundity sharply but carries a survival cost, a classic reproduction trade-off, and also improves two growth transitions a little.

library(ggplot2)
library(dplyr)
library(tidyr)
Code behind this output; later chunks use it, so run it first
te_ink <- "#16241d"; te_body <- "#2c3a31"; te_forest <- "#275139"
te_label <- "#46604a"; te_sage <- "#93a87f"; te_paper <- "#f5f4ee"
te_line <- "#dad9ca"; te_gold <- "#c9b458"; te_deep <- "#1d5b4e"
te_brick <- "#b5534e"; te_faint <- "#5d6b61"
theme_te <- function(base_size = 12) {
  theme_minimal(base_size = base_size) +
    theme(text = element_text(colour = te_body),
          plot.title = element_text(colour = te_ink, face = "bold"),
          plot.subtitle = element_text(colour = te_faint),
          axis.title = element_text(colour = te_label),
          axis.text = element_text(colour = te_body),
          panel.grid.minor = element_blank(),
          panel.grid.major = element_line(colour = te_line, linewidth = 0.3),
          strip.text = element_text(colour = te_ink, face = "bold"),
          plot.background = element_rect(fill = te_paper, colour = NA),
          panel.background = element_rect(fill = te_paper, colour = NA),
          legend.position = "none")
}
A_control <- matrix(c(0,    0,    1.0,
                      0.30, 0.30, 0,
                      0,    0.26, 0.90), nrow = 3, byrow = TRUE)
A_treat   <- matrix(c(0,    0,    1.8,
                      0.34, 0.30, 0,
                      0,    0.30, 0.80), nrow = 3, byrow = TRUE)

lambda <- function(A) {
  ev <- eigen(A); Re(ev$values[which.max(Re(ev$values))])
}
lam_c <- lambda(A_control); lam_t <- lambda(A_treat)
c(lambda_control = lam_c, lambda_treatment = lam_t, delta_lambda = lam_t - lam_c)
  lambda_control lambda_treatment     delta_lambda 
       1.0090260        1.0390761        0.0300501 

The control grows at almost exactly replacement, about 1.009, and the treatment a little faster, about 1.039, a difference in growth of about 0.030. On its own that tells you the treatment helped slightly. It does not tell you why, given that the treatment nearly doubled fecundity yet also cut adult survival.

Sensitivities at the midpoint

The decomposition weights each vital-rate difference by the sensitivity of growth to that element. Caswell’s recommendation is to evaluate the sensitivities at the mean of the two matrices, which keeps the approximation symmetric and accurate. The sensitivity of the dominant eigenvalue to element (i, j) is the reproductive value of stage i times the abundance of stage j, divided by their weighted product.

sensitivity <- function(A) {
  ev <- eigen(A); i <- which.max(Re(ev$values))
  w <- Re(ev$vectors[, i])
  evL <- eigen(t(A)); iL <- which.max(Re(evL$values))
  v <- Re(evL$vectors[, iL])
  outer(v, w) / sum(v * w)
}
A_mid <- (A_control + A_treat) / 2
S_mid <- sensitivity(A_mid)
round(S_mid, 3)
      [,1]  [,2]  [,3]
[1,] 0.119 0.053 0.087
[2,] 0.380 0.169 0.277
[3,] 0.977 0.434 0.712

The sensitivity matrix shows the familiar pattern for a long-lived species: growth is far more sensitive to adult survival, the bottom-right element, than to fecundity, the top-right one. That gap is what will overturn the raw ranking.

The contributions

Each contribution is the difference in a matrix element multiplied by its midpoint sensitivity. Summed over all elements, the contributions recover the difference in growth.

dA <- A_treat - A_control
contr <- dA * S_mid

cells <- list(c(1, 3), c(3, 3), c(2, 1), c(3, 2))
labels <- c("Fecundity (large adult)", "Adult survival (large stasis)",
            "Growth small to medium", "Growth medium to large")
tab <- data.frame(
  element = labels,
  raw_difference = sapply(cells, function(k) dA[k[1], k[2]]),
  sensitivity = sapply(cells, function(k) round(S_mid[k[1], k[2]], 3)),
  contribution = sapply(cells, function(k) round(contr[k[1], k[2]], 4)))
tab
                        element raw_difference sensitivity contribution
1       Fecundity (large adult)           0.80       0.087       0.0694
2 Adult survival (large stasis)          -0.10       0.712      -0.0712
3        Growth small to medium           0.04       0.380       0.0152
4        Growth medium to large           0.04       0.434       0.0174
c(sum_of_contributions = sum(contr), delta_lambda = lam_t - lam_c,
  residual = (lam_t - lam_c) - sum(contr))
sum_of_contributions         delta_lambda             residual 
        0.0307441647         0.0300500989        -0.0006940658 

The contributions sum to about 0.031, against a true difference in growth of about 0.030. The residual, under one thousandth, is the second-order curvature the linear decomposition drops; for differences this size it is negligible. That closeness is the check that the decomposition is trustworthy.

Now read the table. Fecundity has by far the largest raw difference, a rise of 0.8 that nearly doubles it, but its contribution is only about +0.069 because growth is barely sensitive to fecundity. Adult survival falls by only 0.1, an eighth of the fecundity change, yet its contribution is about minus 0.071, the largest in magnitude of the four, because growth is about eight times more sensitive to it. The biggest raw change is not the biggest contribution.

res <- data.frame(short = c("Fecundity", "Adult survival", "Growth S->M", "Growth M->L"),
                  contr = sapply(cells, function(k) contr[k[1], k[2]]),
                  raw = sapply(cells, function(k) dA[k[1], k[2]]))
res$sign <- ifelse(res$contr >= 0, "pos", "neg")
res1 <- res |> arrange(contr) |> mutate(short = factor(short, levels = short))

ggplot(res1, aes(contr, short, fill = sign)) +
  geom_col(width = 0.62) +
  geom_vline(xintercept = 0, colour = te_faint, linewidth = 0.4) +
  scale_fill_manual(values = c(pos = te_forest, neg = te_brick)) +
  geom_text(aes(label = sprintf("%+.3f", contr),
                hjust = ifelse(contr >= 0, -0.15, 1.15)),
            colour = te_body, size = 3.1) +
  labs(title = "Which vital-rate differences drive the change in growth",
       subtitle = sprintf("Contributions sum approximately to the growth difference of %+.3f", lam_t - lam_c),
       x = "Contribution to the change in growth", y = NULL) +
  coord_cartesian(xlim = c(-0.095, 0.095)) +
  theme_te()
Horizontal bars: adult survival extends left in red as a large negative contribution, fecundity extends right in green as a large positive one, two small green growth bars between them.
Figure 1: Contribution of each vital-rate difference to the change in growth; positive contributions raise it, negative lower it, and they sum approximately to the total.

The trade-off is now legible. The fecundity gain of about +0.069 and the survival cost of about minus 0.071 nearly cancel: on its own the dramatic reproductive boost adds more than the whole net improvement, but the survival cost takes back slightly more than that. What tips the balance positive is the pair of modest growth-transition gains, together worth about +0.033. A summary that reported only the fecundity increase would have the biology backwards.

Raw change against contribution

Placing the raw differences and the contributions side by side makes the reordering explicit. Fecundity dominates the left panel; in the right panel the adult-survival bar is only slightly longer than the fecundity bar, so the two largest contributions are nearly equal and opposite.

ord <- res |> arrange(desc(abs(raw))) |> pull(short)
long <- res |>
  transmute(short,
            `Raw vital-rate difference` = raw,
            `LTRE contribution` = contr) |>
  pivot_longer(-short, names_to = "panel", values_to = "value") |>
  mutate(short = factor(short, levels = rev(ord)),
         panel = factor(panel, levels = c("Raw vital-rate difference", "LTRE contribution")),
         sign = ifelse(value >= 0, "pos", "neg"))

ggplot(long, aes(value, short, fill = sign)) +
  geom_col(width = 0.62) +
  geom_vline(xintercept = 0, colour = te_faint, linewidth = 0.4) +
  scale_fill_manual(values = c(pos = te_forest, neg = te_brick)) +
  facet_wrap(~panel, scales = "free_x") +
  labs(title = "Biggest raw change is not the biggest contribution",
       subtitle = "Fecundity has the largest raw change;\nadult survival, far more sensitive, contributes most",
       x = NULL, y = NULL) +
  theme_te()
Two panels sharing vital-rate labels: on the left the fecundity bar is by far the longest, on the right the adult-survival bar is the longest and negative, only slightly longer than the fecundity bar, showing the ranking swap.
Figure 2: Raw vital-rate differences (left) and their LTRE contributions (right); the largest raw change, fecundity, is not the largest contribution.

Prospective and retrospective, side by side

The two analyses answer different questions and should not be confused. A sensitivity or elasticity analysis is prospective: it takes one matrix and asks which rate to target to raise growth in future, regardless of how much that rate actually varies. An LTRE is retrospective: it takes two matrices that already differ and asks which of the differences that happened accounts for the gap in growth. A rate can be highly sensitive yet contribute nothing to an LTRE because it did not differ between the groups, and a rate can differ a lot yet contribute little because growth is insensitive to it. Reading the two together, the prospective sensitivity from the companion post and the retrospective contribution here, is how you tell what could matter from what did.

References

Caswell H 1989. Ecological Modelling 46(3-4):221-237 (10.1016/0304-3800(89)90019-7).

Caswell H 1996. Ecological Modelling 88(1-3):73-82 (10.1016/0304-3800(95)00070-4).

Caswell H 2000. Ecology 81(3):619-627 (10.1890/0012-9658(2000)081[0619:PARPAT]2.0.CO;2).

de Kroon H, Plaisier A, van Groenendael J, Caswell H 1986. Ecology 67(5):1427-1431 (10.2307/1938700).

Download the R codeReport a problem with this page

Newsletter

Get updates by email

An occasional email when tutorials are added or substantially corrected. No spam; unsubscribe anytime.

By subscribing you agree to receive these emails and confirm your address once. See the privacy policy.